2020.11.20 16:03 peacejoyhappy Do not join Transamerica, World Financial Group ( affiliated with Aegon) or any MLM.
In this review, I am going to use government based articles to explain why this setup at WFG and MLMs in general are a very bad idea of nearly everyone involved.The information in this post includes answers to why MLMs are immoral, target minorities populations, and exploits people for money, and how MLMs breed poverty in already poverty-stricken communities (Latinos & African Americans). I mention race here because racial bias is important to consider when investing MLMs. I am going to show you valid points on why, with a foundational basis on math and facts to explain this to you, but I’m going to give you my personal story and thoughts as well. You should read the links from government websites to get the full picture on MLMs and World Financial Group, Transamerica, and all other MLMs = is all the same pyramid shaped system.
I’m going to demonstrate the moral point, that all pyramid-shaped MLMs are immoral and exploitative, even with WFG, who sells insurance policies, which is supposed to be a helpful benefit, right? Like my WFG friend tells me, "you're so confused. We help so many people. I know all about pyramids. They teach us all about pyramids."My Background in MLMs:
MLMs will never work unless you joined in the very very early stages.I almost joined an MLM 3x! I know, it's sad....
Government Article on why 99% of people in MLMs lose money and probability odds, including breakdowns of finances for very popular MLM company agents: | https://www.ftc.gov/sites/default/files/documents/public_comments/trade-regulation-rule-disclosure-requirements-and-prohibitions-concerning-business-opportunities-ftc.r511993-00008%C2%A0/00008-57281.pdf When the Federal Trade Commission ruled in 1979 that Amway was not an illegal pyramid scheme—mainly because legitimate products were offered, the floodgates were opened and multi-level marketing programs began to proliferate. But what is often ignored is the fact that MLM programs are still pyramid schemes, modified by a variety of compensation systems that change the character of the pyramid, but not the essential pyramidal concept, motivation, and effects. The pyramid concept in MLM is seen in multiple layers of distributors, with lower level distributors contributing income to an ―upline who may have little to do with a given sale. | |
---|---|---|
USA Federal Commission quoted from this website in their APA | http://skepdic.com/pyramid.html "A pyramid scheme is called a pyramid scheme because of the shape of a pyramid: a three dimensional triangle. If a pyramid were started by a human being at the top with just 10 people beneath him, and 100 beneath them, and 1000 beneath them, etc., the pyramid would involve everyone on earth in just ten layers of people with one con man on top. The human pyramid would be about 60 feet high and the bottom layer would have more than 4.5 billion people! Thus, in very short order, 10 recruiting 10 and so on would reach 10 billion, well in excess of the earth's population**.** If the entire population of earth were 5 billion and we all got involved in a pyramid scheme, the bottom layer would consist of about 90 percent of the planet, i.e., about 4.5 billion people. Thus, for 500 million people to be WINNERS, 4.5 billion must be LOSERS. | |
Scholarly Article on The Behavioral Economics of Multilevel Marketing.... | MLMs and pyramid schemes partially overlap: Some MLM companies are pyramid schemes and some pyramid schemes consist of MLM companies. The resemblance between the two is made salient by the organizational structure: Pyramid schemes ask those individuals at the base of the pyramid to contribute to the higher levels, with the promise of a reward provided entirely from those levels below the individual. Similarly, MLMs offer the promise of profits to its consultants, but those profits stem from two streams: Commissions from direct sales and commissions from recruiting new clients. Indeed, one early article attempting to distinguish pyramid schemes from MLM models pointed out that “the investor's pecuniary benefit [of a pyramid scheme] derives primarily from his success in inducing additional persons to participate in the plan.” Most of the money made from every WFG agent is through recruits verses insurance sales. https://repository.uchastings.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1176&context=hastings_business_law_journal | |
A Government Article from Federal Trade Commission | https://www.consumer.ftc.gov/articles/0065-multi-level-marketing-businesses-and-pyramid-schemes | |
World Financial Group Tries to Silence People Speaking Out | People at WFG created instagram accounts and harassed him to get his video taken down: https://Ωwww.youtube.com/watch?v=flugTRSTZoo | |
Other popular MLM FACTS | ALL MLM's work for the top 1% to make hundreds of thousands and the lowest to make nearly nothing. For example, 99% of all Arbonne distributors earned an average income of $87.36 annually whereas the top .04% earned an average income of $330,516.” | |
Popular MLMs with the same results of 99% losing money: Mona Vie (2008.) 99% lost Nu Skin (2008) 99% lost Herbalife (2008). Arbonne Int’l (2007) Amway/Quixtar (2001)In every case, using the analytical framework described above, the loss rate for all of these MLMs ranged from 99.12% to 99.97%, with an average of 99.6% of participants losing money. On average, one in 238 actually profited after subtracting expenses, and 996 out of 1,000 lost money – to say nothing of the time invested. The most liberal assumptions that could reasonably be used in favor of the MLMs were applied to this table of MLM loss rates. Using the more realistic assumptions discussed in prior chapters, the average loss rate for these MLMs would have averaged no better than 99.9% - with less than one in 1,000 profiting significantly. Also, I would estimate that the number of new recruits who wind up receiving the promised substantial “residual income” held out at MLM opportunity meetings is no better than one in 25,000 recruits! | ||
Documentaries on MLMs | "Betting On Zero" Herbalife https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBmlMa6RCV4 | |
Herbalife Product MLM (Study other MLMs to see the setup is just faulty because it's a pyramid) | https://www.cnbc.com/selling-the-american-dream/ | |
"I Joined An MLM To Earn Extra Money -- Here's What Actually Happened" | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mw2ijFNd1HI | |
TED Talk: "How to Spot a Pyramid Scheme" | https://www.ted.com/talks/stacie_bosley_how_to_spot_a_pyramid_scheme/transcript?language=en | |
I know some of you are thinking …”that WFG is not the same! Not all MLMs are bad! We sell insurance and help people secure a financial future.”Remember, ask yourself this question: If I ONLY sold the product would I make a good enough living without recruits? If the answer is no, you should leave now.
My answer to that is it’s still bad. Why? Because you build funds for yourself and the top of the pyramid by recruiting to uneducated people who know less about finance than you when 99% of all of you fail. That means, more people in poverty lose money and I think that's pretty bad, especially now with more attention to minority communities and the Brianna Taylor trial ....we are trying to have more diversity in the workplace to support inclusion of all races to have better economic gains for minorities families and futures.
An MLM peoples' odds of being successful are almost zero at this phase of entry into any MLM. The insurance sales is a cunning WFG tactic because it may help people stay around longer, but the business model of a pyramid is still there and it is still overall immoral and hurts minority communities. Why?Remember, the government fact is that 99% of people who join an MLM lose money! Facts are facts. Also, people can get better insurance policies with other companies than offered at WFG.
Poverty-stricken communities pay more money than they ever get out of it with an MLM. They also get their friends and family involved, a requirement for started in WFG, which means many people are affected and lose money by paying for trainings, licenses, and even the first few people YOU bring in when you start are actually commissions made for their upline person, not you.
They want you to think YOU can be one of the top successful people financially and that it is a HARD job and it is effort gives reward.People at WFG cannot make enough money just selling ONLY the product, but through recruits. This is where your RED FLAG ALERT should go off. Remember, the government article above says, "Promoters emphasize recruiting new distributors for your sales network as the real way to make money. Walk away. In a legitimate MLM program, you should be able to make money just by selling the product."
They want you to think the long and hardworking game is how you win…but the reality is that if you were not the first to join, you will always lose more money for your effort because that’s how the pyramid shape works.
Even with insurance, people at WFG cannot sustain an income only through their insurance sales. The longer you stay, the more money you bring them. When everyone recruits everyone, you create a lot of competition in the city, but even then the competition does not last because people cannot live on an unsustainable model. That means, they put more money in than they ever got it. It's a faulty business model and expectations of sales are unrealistic. Selling insurance takes a while and that's how they keep you going for longer, using that logic....
The government article linked above states, “As indicated above, one can do much better at the gaming tables in Las Vegas. And a person need not risk his or her social capital – treasured relationships with friends and family one has spent a lifetime cultivating. “
MLMs want you to think in the here and now. Just be present with life!
WFG wants people to think their company is different, like all MLMs…this company says they are helping people with life insurance policies, but the truth is that is how they can operate legally. WFG is cunning and smart, as they found the government loophole and that by selling services, the WFG MLM keeps going and the people involved think their dreams will come true, that they will achieve the success of those above them.
Another truth, WFG’s insurance commissions are lower than in other industries and keeps people in it for longer since building up clients from an insurance takes time…. The more time they hold recruits, the more successful they are at feeding the top and their uplines.
Ask someone from an MLM if they ONLY sold the product with no recruits, would they make a livable income? If the answer is no, they need to get out.
2020.11.20 04:02 peacejoyhappy Do not join WFG, Transamerica, or any MLM! Let's use facts to discuss why....
Can money be made in MLM (Multi-level Marketing)? Yes, but only for the top 1% who join in the very beginning. submitted by peacejoyhappy to antiMLM [link] [comments] Who am I? I am a woman who made this post because of my brief experience in MLMs and I am someone who wants to see her friend out of an MLM once I found out the truth. Because my friend is completely brainwashed by World Financial Group, an insurance-based MLM, I'd like to share everything I learned trying to convince her to get out of a pyramid-shaped company that relies on recruits to make the majority of their money. Perhaps this can help you or a friend. If so, it is worth all of effort for me. I love my friend very much, just like you love yours. Let's share the real information of what MLMs do to impoverished communities through facts. Scroll down for government article links on MLMs and why 99% of people in them lose money. The way a pyramid is shaped means that only the top 1% in the pyramid make money. In order to be in the top 1%, typically you have to join an MLM in the first year. Here's a fact: World Financial Group began in 2011. Ummm...it’s 2020 right now. If you join WFG, not much is going to happen for you now. WFG began too long ago to make money in it today for new recruits, but they need recruits to keep money funneling to them for the top 1%. In this review, I am going to use government based articles to explain why this setup at WFG and MLMs in general are a very bad idea of nearly everyone involved.The information in this post includes answers to why MLMs are immoral, target minorities populations, and exploits people for money, and how MLMs breed poverty in already poverty-stricken communities (Latinos & African Americans). I mention race here because racial bias is important to consider when investing MLMs. I am going to show you valid points on why, with a foundational basis on math and facts to explain this to you, but I’m going to give you my personal story and thoughts as well. You should read the links from government websites to get the full picture on MLMs and World Financial Group, Transamerica, and all other MLMs = is all the same pyramid shaped system. I’m going to demonstrate the moral point, that all pyramid-shaped MLMs are immoral and exploitative, even with WFG, who sells insurance policies, which is supposed to be a helpful benefit, right? Like my WFG friend tells me, "you're so confused. We help so many people. I know all about pyramids. They teach us all about pyramids."My Background in MLMs: My ex’s father was an MLM expert in the company MonaVie (2008). We will call him H. In the past, I used to be able to google H and easily find information from his name and his success, but it is like he disappeared from the internet. I used to admire H a lot. He was an African American man, tall, skinny, and very educated. He used to be homeless, but got into MLMs and other businesses, making a lot of money later. I went to his conferences for MonaVie with his 20's age son, and I recall he held his son a spot higher up in the company bracket so that his son could begin selling with a solid downline from recruits. From his son's words, H made approximately $300,000 per month for having people underneath him in an MLM. I was impressed because I thought MLMs were amazing if someone could make that much money. When I looked up H's website, he charged $500 per phone call for his advice. I thought, in my early twenties, "Wow, this must be a smart man to charge that much for advice." Also, H was an engineer, which required a level of understanding in science and math beyond my scope. I remember listening to H's talks and he was a gifted speaker and dreamer ... he had a way with people and he recruited a lot of people beneath him. H was in the top 1% and made elite status in the MLM company. What H and other did not tell you is that no one except the first people that joined ever made the kind of money H made, not even close, despite all of the conferences he had in people signing up as new recruits. Reflecting on H and what I know now, I am pretty disappointed that he knew how this worked, but still found it just fine to make all of these dreamers under him purchase products and lose money for his gain. It's a greedy world for the top MLM people. MLMs will never work unless you joined in the very very early stages.I almost joined an MLM 3x! I know, it's sad.... The last time it happened I was in a Chipotle getting lunch and surrounded by mostly men in business suits. One African American man approached me and we had a discussion about business. He ended up buying me a book (it was actually a good book) and that made our connection. Then, he tells me that someone higher up in the business, who made a lot of money, explained to him that he can change his life if he follows this system in Amway. It is a very touching story. Soon enough, and some Zoom calls later, I have to pass this reflective test and questionnaire to prove that I am someone that has the motivation and drive to be mentored by him. I was supposed to feel honored when I passed. After the passed first test, I am about to attend a meeting where everyone is going to clap for me because I passed the first step into this organizational pyramid called Amway.... Facts: 99.9% lost money in Amway. Check out the government article, first link. My Amway mentor had a construction business and that was how he was doing well financially. there is no way he was able to leave Amway and retire on his benefits from the MLM. Despite people saying he was about to retire from Amway and how well he was doing, he was probably too ashamed to admit he spent 10 years and all of his extra time thinking he was going to retire early because of Amway. I also question that supposedly rich man in his story that he could have racially targeted this person to him a worker and slave to Amway for losses, not gains.... I ended up googling Amway and found another man wrote a book on how Amway scammed him out of his life savings, despite being a top agent and never seeing any of the funds the top agents promoted. Everyone thought he was successful below him, but the truth was that he was in a lot of debt. Since all pyramid-shaped business models in MLMs work the same way with building a business based on recruits and the products purchased, below will be examples why the MLM pyramid model (**which is in all MLMs) is not a moral business model. Let me explain.... and please chime in if I said anything incorrect, you wonderful reddit people.
“Promoters emphasize recruiting new distributors for your sales network as the real way to make money. Walk away. In a legitimate MLM program, you should be able to make money just by selling the product (government article quote from above). My friend thinks WFG just has bad advertising; that is what they tell her inside and she believes it. I know some of you are thinking …”that WFG is not the same! Not all MLMs are bad! We sell insurance and help people secure a financial future.”Remember, ask yourself this question: If I ONLY sold the product would I make a good enough living without recruits? If the answer is no, you should leave now. An MLM peoples' odds of being successful are almost zero at this phase of entry into any MLM. The insurance sales is a cunning WFG tactic because it may help people stay around longer, but the business model of a pyramid is still there and it is still overall immoral and hurts minority communities. Why?Remember, the government fact is that 99% of people who join an MLM lose money! Facts are facts. Also, people can get better insurance policies with other companies than offered at WFG. WFG is a VERY clever and cunning MLM by using insurance, but it is STILL AN MLM. What MLMs want you to think: They want you to think YOU can be one of the top successful people financially and that it is a HARD job and it is effort gives reward.People at WFG cannot make enough money just selling ONLY the product, but through recruits. This is where your RED FLAG ALERT should go off. Remember, the government article above says, "Promoters emphasize recruiting new distributors for your sales network as the real way to make money. Walk away. In a legitimate MLM program, you should be able to make money just by selling the product." When my friend told me she needed 10 people to watch her training to pass her exam at WFG, I went to help her. During me helping her, they switched the energy on me and tried to also recruit me. What was an innocent act of kindness on my part was no longer all that was wanted from me, but I was curious about the business and I researched and googled it more. I got a lot of text messages from her after that to join her in conferences. The successful people are the only ones successful. The people claiming success….well, it will never happen for them. A lot of people in their uplines lie and pretend they make more than they do, but they end up feeling ashamed they never got the riches for all of their hard work. It's a sad world we live in and since my friend cannot hear me, maybe one of you will instead. Here are some text exchanges I had with my World Financial Group friend. I am in the green colored boxes: I am telling her in this conversation about how MLMs are setup. Here below she refers me her upline guy so he can explain the things she cannot. This systemic approach also increases are chances of recruiting me. Notice how she says she can never lose money she never made? In an earlier conversation, she told me she pays for conferences, so right now she is only losing money by their affiliation. I am asking her how much money she is making profit after her working there for one year. Do you see her response? She diverts from it and immediately says I am not being fair? She and I have had many very close conversations in the past but she will not reveal to me that she is making ....which is nothing at World Financial Group after 1 full year, which is probably blames on herself despite her working very hard in lots of trainings and meetings. Below notice how she says I can \"loose time not making money and can't loose money from something she never set up?\" This makes no sense to me with her being involved with them for 1 total year. Below I tell her I am not going to meet with her upline, but she does not notice what I said. Later she gets upset with me that I committed to meet him when I said I no longer wanted to (not pictured, so you have to take my word on it). Also, I think it's weird she has never been upset with me before in our friendship and she takes me not meeting him as a personal attack. Also, here she says she \"cannot solve everything today,\" probably a brainwashed technique on staying in the moment and being oblivious to the MLM pyramid. She says she knows \"the odds,\" too. Okay, let's go gamble and you have a kid...since our odds are higher there? She does not know the real odds of those she targets in minority populations for the pressured recruiting tactics and signup fees. Below she thinks I have a \"negative view\" on MLMs. It's not about my opinion, but science. She is taught to think that some pyramids are good, like her MLM World Financial Group. Which people would disagree? The ones in your MLM? Here she thinks it is wrong that I am going to write articles on people not joining MLMs and I have convinced myself it is a scam and calls me ignorant. Here is says she's 38 and talks about all of her business knowledge. She told me throughout our texts, about 10x explaining that \"I am not stupid.\" I never once called her stupid or ever believed she was. I have never called her a mean name ever! She also put me in the groups of her abusive ex and narcissistic boyfriend! I've dated a narc and that's seriously offensive. I would give the shirt off my back to anyone in need. That is why I am doing everything I can to help my friend get out of this MLM! She is so tied to her positive experiences in this MLM that anyone opposing it is a threat. This MLM has her thinking that having a regular job is evil and that it's normal to need up to 4 income sources. I have 3 incomes sources, but an MLM is not a good one. I want to say....Sweetie, what's evil is MLMs who take 99% of people's money and rely on recruits in a system that only feeds the top 1%, making the bottom workers like her PAY for trainings and events, get their friends to pay... and make very low commissions for insurance preying on minorities. She does not think that statistics or math runs the world, making her in total denial of the pyramid MLM she is involved with. She wants woman empowerment and thinks this MLM, primarily female, will be more empowered by staying involved and motivating each other. Since most MLMs are females, she is connecting to that group energy and motivation, keeping her involved to keep her self-esteem high. https://preview.redd.it/y5y5y1a0kc061.png?width=750&format=png&auto=webp&s=384c09e68430545dfd5c0fd8d6423a30a4871ec5 Conclusion: Since all MLMs only make money in the top 1%, her recruiting people will never make her enough to support herself from recruits. While she may continue to stay in it making subpar insurance commissions, she is making less compared to other insurance companies, keeping her financial situation down unless she takes on more jobs to support herself for a good life. If she continues to stay, this MLM will steal all of her extra time that she could have had with her child. She instead will stay in an MLM that ultimately promotes more poverty, even though I know she is passionate about the opposite, which is helping impoverished populations that she is targeting for financial advice. She feels that in WFG she is helping those more than harming, but I would disagree. She would better to be involved in a non-MLM insurance company with higher commissions for her efforts. Reddit, she is one of the purest hearted people and that is why I am trying to help her, but if I can help convince even one person to not join an MLM, then writing this was totally worth it. |
2019.08.06 21:34 Josie324 Anyone remember MonaVie?
2019.03.23 21:40 anotherxyztravis My MLM experience with Monavie
2018.08.20 18:46 Throwawayforreason10 [ Update] Are you fucking kidding me?-- Spouse wants to join an MLM.. Won't take no for an answer
2018.02.20 06:37 GlamorousSloth The Time my Mother Thought She was Going to Hangout with a Friend.